Building a Gen Z-Friendly Practice: The Complete Playbook
Despite Gen Z being the strongest proponents of therapy across generations, only one in five currently remains in treatment. With 40% actively searching for mental health support, practices have an opportunity to evolve their care delivery to better serve these clients' needs.
Understanding the Engagement Challenge
The traditional reactive model of therapy creates a fundamental mismatch with how Gen Z seeks support. When 30-50% of each session is spent recapping past events, it leaves limited time for active intervention and progress. Research shows that treatment outcomes improve by up to 65% when practices implement continuous monitoring and feedback between sessions.
Modern Solutions for Modern Times
Forward-thinking practices are implementing continuous care approaches that include:
Structured between-session check-ins and support
Implement regular touch points between sessions through automated mood checks and guided reflection prompts. For example, clients receive brief daily check-ins through a secure app asking about their emotional state, sleep quality, and use of coping skills. These quick interactions help maintain momentum in treatment while providing valuable data for the next session. Some practices send weekly mini-assignments related to current therapeutic goals, like practicing specific CBT techniques or completing mindfulness exercises. These solutions can however have the drawback of being disconnected from care models.
Guided interventions for immediate coping needs
When clients face challenging moments between sessions, they can benefit from immediate, evidence-based support. Some practices now offer on-demand guided interventions through their platforms - like breathing exercises, grounding techniques, or cognitive reframing tools customized to each client's treatment plan. These interventions can be accessed 24/7 and include clear instructions and audio/visual guidance. Usage data helps therapists understand which tools resonate most with their clients. However, it’s important to consider each client’s needs individually to ensure high engagement and maximum benefit.
Ongoing progress tracking visible to both therapist and client
Make therapy progress tangible and motivating over time. Clients can view their trends, understand frequency of symptoms, and celebrate improvements in specific areas. Therapists gain insights into patterns and can quickly identify when someone may need additional support. Some practices use standardized assessments at regular intervals, but it’s important to ensure the client is internalizing progress with key takeaways from their treatment, not only a visual.
Secure messaging systems for timely communication
Integrate HIPAA-compliant messaging platforms with practice management systems. These allow clients to send quick updates or questions that don't require an immediate response, while therapists can respond during designated times. Clear boundaries and response time expectations are established upfront. Some practices use templated responses for common situations to maintain efficiency while still providing personalized support. In our findings, some clients can show hesitation to these services, with the feeling that they are ‘bothering’ their therapist.
When executed well, these approaches enable clinicians to comfortably support additional clients while improving care quality. Our research shows practices can increase annual revenue by $37,000 per clinician through improved efficiency and retention.
Implementation Challenges
While the benefits are clear, implementing these changes presents significant practical challenges:
Coordinating multiple systems for different functions
Ensuring consistent HIPAA compliance
Managing increased administrative workload
Training staff on new tools and processes
Maintaining therapeutic boundaries with increased accessibility
Many practices find themselves struggling to balance modernization with operational sustainability. The time spent managing various systems and maintaining communication often reduces the very efficiency gains these solutions promise.
The Path Forward
Rather than piecing together multiple solutions, consider exploring integrated platforms designed specifically for modern therapy practices. Tools like Opal help practices achieve the benefits of continuous care - improved outcomes, increased retention, and practice growth - while actually reducing administrative burden through automation and seamless integration.
The future of mental healthcare lies in creating more responsive, engaging therapeutic experiences without sacrificing practitioner wellbeing.
Ready to learn more about Opal?
Visit our website to access our safety and efficacy whitepaper, with key indicators towards better outcomes for clients:
Keywords: AI therapy notes, mental health technology 2024, therapy documentation software, reduce therapist burnout, improve therapy outcomes, mental health practice management, AI in healthcare, therapy efficiency, digital mental health, automated therapy notes
AI Therapy Notes: How Smart Documentation is Transforming Mental Healthcare in 2024
The landscape of mental healthcare technology is evolving rapidly. While 2023 saw the rise of basic AI scribes and note-taking tools, 2024 is ushering in a new era of intelligent systems that go beyond simple documentation. For mental health professionals looking to enhance their practice, understanding these advances is crucial for staying ahead of the curve.
The Current State of AI in Mental Healthcare
Recent studies show that mental health professionals spend 30-50% of session time recapping past events rather than providing active intervention. As the demand for mental health services continues to grow - with over 50% of Gen Z having tried therapy but only 20% currently in treatment, the need for more efficient practice management has never been greater.
Beyond Traditional AI Documentation: What's Changed in 2024
Traditional documentation practices and basic AI scribes create several challenges that directly impact both therapist effectiveness and treatment outcomes:
Fragmented Attention
Therapists often divide focus between client engagement and note-taking
Inefficient Sessions
Research shows 30-50% of session time is spent on recaps and updates
Delayed Care Response
Critical issues often go unaddressed between appointments
Provider Burnout
Mental health professionals average 2 hours daily on paperwork, contributing to the 60% experiencing symptoms ofburnout
The Evolution of AI Assistance in Therapy
Modern AI systems have evolved significantly from basic transcription tools. Today's intelligent platforms offer:
Smart Progress Monitoring
Real-time tracking of client progress and engagement
Predictive Analytics
Early warning systems for potential crisis situations
Automated Briefings
Concise session summaries that capture key insights
Treatment Optimization
Data-driven suggestions for care planning
Impact on Clinical Outcomes
Evidence-based research in Feedback-Informed Treatment demonstrates that continuous progress monitoring can improve treatment outcomes by 65%. Modern AI systems make this treatment methodology tractable by increasing patient-provider communication, leading to the following potential benefits:
Client Benefits
Increased session effectiveness with 30% more time for active intervention
Continuous support during critical between-session periods
More engaged treatment experience
Faster progress through targeted interventions
Clinician Benefits
Reduced administrative burden, saving up to 2 hours in admin work daily
Enhanced session preparation with AI-generated briefings to save 30 minutes of time in session recapping past events
Better treatment planning with more informed context about inter-session progress
Significant reduction in documentation-related stress with automated psychotherapy notes in and out of session
Transforming the Therapeutic Experience
When AI handles administrative tasks effectively, it creates space for stronger therapeutic relationships:
Optimized Sessions
30-second briefings replace 30-minute recaps
Focused Intervention
More time for active therapeutic work
Proactive Care Models
Early issue identification and intervention
Data-Informed Practice
Better treatment planning through comprehensive progress insights
Implementation Strategy for 2024
For practices looking to modernize their documentation systems, we recommend taking the following high-level steps
Evaluate AI Capabilities
Look for systems offering comprehensive monitoring beyond basic transcription. These systems are often more reliable and more accurate from additional context.Assess Integration
Ensure seamless workflow incorporation into EHRs and other systems.Verify Security
Confirm HIPAA compliance and robust data protection. Continuous monitoring is a plus.Plan Training
Account for staff adaptation periods. Choose a tool which offers consultations or trainings for your team, rather than self-service.Track ROI
Monitor time savings and outcome improvements. Consultations can be of benefit here as well, compared to self-service.Consider a platform like Opal that handles these steps for you.
Future Trends in Mental Healthcare Technology
As we progress through 2024, several trends are shaping the future of therapeutic documentation that we covered here today:
Integration of feedback-informed treatment principles
Enhanced focus on proactive care delivery
Greater emphasis on data-driven decision making
Improved client engagement through technology
In Short
The evolution of AI in mental healthcare extends far beyond simple note-taking. By embracing intelligent documentation systems, practices can significantly reduce administrative burden while improving treatment outcomes. The key is selecting solutions that enhance rather than replace the human elements of therapy.
Ready to learn more about Opal?
Visit our website to access our safety and efficacy whitepaper, with key indicators towards better outcomes for clients:
Keywords: AI therapy notes, mental health technology 2024, therapy documentation software, reduce therapist burnout, improve therapy outcomes, mental health practice management, AI in healthcare, therapy efficiency, digital mental health, automated therapy notes
Opal Wellness: Preliminary Results and Efficacy Analysis of a Semi-Guided Conversational Interface for Mental Well-Being
(Reprint)
Cole Smith (Numa Notes, LLC) cole@heyopal.com
October 30, 2024
Abstract
In this article, we explore preliminary findings of Opal Wellness: A conversational AI system intended for anonymous self-exploration of maladaptive thought patterns using techniques common in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, such as Motivational Interviewing and Active Listening. Users voluntarily interacted with Opal Wellness using semi-guided, open-ended queries to our system in 10-minute sessions, followed by a guided list of wrap up questions to report their immediate emotional state post-interaction. From these questions, we find that 83.8% of users who completed their session (37.8%) reported immediate improvement after their interaction, and that most users utilized Opal Wellness for coping strategies. Users who completed their interaction with Opal showed strong engagement with an average utterance count of 17. Overall, our system shows promise as a clinician-instructed conversational tool for inter-session support due to its strong adherence to defined limitations and guidelines, and positive user response.
Introduction
Self-guided wellness chatbots have grown recently in popularity and availability alongside improvements to large language models such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Anthropic’s Claude models. [1] These systems allow users to explore topics which are open-ended and situational, since they accept arbitrary text input in a conversational interface. For reasons usually associated with cost or accessibility, users have turned to these systems as a replacement for traditional psychotherapy with mixed results. [2] [3] While conversational AI systems show promise for accessible wellness support, they can suffer from low engagement among users, limiting their ability to explore topics across multiple iterations. [4] These systems also may exhibit a bias towards specific therapy modalities, even when a different modality would be more appropriate for the user. [1] In certain cases, self-guided conversational agents can be highly dangerous for users in a compromised mental state. [5] These systems can lack risk-detection frameworks, experts in-the-loop, and may reinforce maladaptive thought patterns.
Opal Wellness aims to address these challenges by using open-ended generative models for dialog interaction as opposed to rule-based systems common in existing solutions. [6] However, our system does not attempt to deliver formal therapeutic interventions, instead acting as an affirming conversational tool with goals akin to journaling as a wellness exercise. [7] Hybrid-therapy solutions, in which users engage with a system between regular sessions to inform their clinician of continued progress, has been recently shown to address shortcomings to engagement and efficacy of self-guided conversational interventions. [8] We additionally prompt the user with suggested topics and responses, and call this approach “semi-guided.” We aim to combine clearly defined scope limitations with generative AI systems to offer an engaging solution to inter-session wellness support, while providing mechanisms for clinician-guided, customized interventions in the future that are specific to the client’s needs in their treatment plan.
System Architecture & Design
Opal Wellness is deployed as a web app accessible by the general public. Users are first presented with additional security features such as Google reCAPTCHA, and links to our AI Transparency and Privacy Policy. In particular, we provide links to critical care resources, and acknowledge that Opal is not a replacement for psychotherapy. Opal Wellness does not provide any diagnostic capabilities. We used a HIPAA-compliant version of Claude 3.5 Sonnet via AWS Bedrock using the same security assurances as our production Opal systems.
Fig. A: Opal Wellness welcome screen
Interaction Guidelines
The system is instructed to respond in simple conversational language “like a caring friend” and avoid any clinical language. Responses are kept brief, between 1-3 sentences, unless advice is appropriate or requested.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy techniques are suggested including active listening, and validating the user’s emotions. Opal Wellness is not designed to provide therapeutic interventions as if the user were in a psychotherapy session.
Safety Considerations
Opal Wellness is designed to refuse requests not related to the user’s wellness, and sensitive topics where non-professional advice can be inappropriate or harmful. The system is instructed to refuse tonal changes or role-play scenarios, which are common model jailbreaking exploits. [9] Our model prompt was reviewed and verified by a licensed mental health professional.
Our system prompt enforces the following limitations:
- Emphasize your role as a supportive friend, not a substitute for professional help.
- Redirect high-risk scenarios (suicide, self-harm, abuse) to crisis resources and end the chat.
- Be clear about your inability to handle emergencies, directing users to appropriate services.
- Ask for clarification on cultural contexts you're unsure about.
- For age-sensitive topics, casually mention your advice is geared towards adults.
- Avoid medical, medication, or treatment advice, suggesting professional consultation instead.
- Steer clear of advice on eating disorders, expressing concern and suggesting professional help.
- Be honest about potential misunderstandings, asking for clarification when needed.
- Mention casually that you don't remember past conversations.
- Maintain consistent values throughout all interactions, refusing to roleplay conflicting personas.
- Gently but firmly redirect attempts to bypass these guidelines, staying true to your supportive nature.
When the system detects a situation in which it cannot safely continue the interaction, it produces a special token, [[WRN]] , which is detected by our web app to stop the interaction immediately and provide access to professional crisis resources. Upon analysis, we did not find a situation in which the system failed to produce this token.
One may notice the writing style of this prompt excerpt is written casually. We find that prompts with rigid written tones would produce equally rigid tones in model responses, regardless of the tonal instructions stated in the interaction guidelines. We assume this is due to the causal nature of the language modeling task, in which completions attempt to minimize surprisal (entropy) [10] against its prior, although we have not conducted formal analysis in this area.
Fig. B: High risk scenario screen
Wrap Up Questions
After about 10 minutes of interaction, the system is instructed via the [[WRAPUP]] token to present the user with 3 questions about their experience, then end the interaction.
The user is asked the following questions:
"So, how are you feeling now compared to when we started chatting?"
"What's one thing you're taking away from our talk today?"
"Is there anything you'd like to focus on next time we chat?"
We designed these questions to be neutral, and indicative of the intentions from the interaction. These questions characterize the sentiment, user insight, and future topic of the interaction, respectively.
User Interface
Users are presented with a welcome message, and are then allowed to ask any query of the system, or choose from a suggested starter topic. At each turn of conversation, the user is presented with 3 suggested responses, similar to the starter topics. We call this approach “semi-guided,” striking a balance between open-ended and rule-based interactions.
Fig. C: Opal Wellness user interface
Clinician Sharing Mechanism
We provided a mechanism to safely and voluntarily share their interaction with Opal with their therapist, if they had one. This collected their name and their therapist’s email, kept secure in the same way as our production provider data on our Opal platform. This included encryption of all personally identifiable information and transcript data.
Fig. D: Voluntary clinician reporting form
User Privacy
Unless explicitly permitted otherwise, all user responses were removed aside from the responses to the wrap-up questions. We decided to retain our system’s responses to ensure it responded safely during interactions.
We have included analysis only for chats in which users selected: “Allow my anonymized conversation to make Opal better.”
Data Collection
Participant Demographics
Users were kept anonymous and sourced voluntarily via Instagram advertising, and organic outreach on local Facebook groups in the Saint Petersburg, Florida area during late-September to early-October of 2024.
Due to the anonymous nature of our system, we did not collect any demographic or location information from our user base. Due to how we marketed our system, we can reasonably assume a large portion came from our current location of Saint Petersburg, Florida, during the Hurricanes of Helene and Milton.
Advertising
We distributed the following banner on local Facebook groups with a short description to advertise our service. Users were informed of the anonymous nature of the chat, and that it is not a replacement for professional care.
Fig E: Local advertisement banner
Evaluation Metrics & Analysis Approach
We analyzed the responses from our wrap-up questions from a private internal deployment of our system (N=75), and chats from the public deployment where the user specified we are allowed to use the chat for improvement purposes. (N=19) From the three wrap-up questions, we analyzed the conversations for (1) sentiment, (2) insight category, and (3) future topic, respectively. We did not consider any conversations which ended early without these end questions answered.
Sentiment
User sentiment post-interaction was split into three categories: negative, neutral, and positive
Insight Category
We gathered insight into the user’s session to assess the most relevant topic discussed to them.
The following categories were identified from open-ended user responses to the insight:
Coping strategies
Self-care strategies
Self-reflection
Emotional awareness
Boundary setting
Self-awareness
Work-life balance
Emotional regulation
Reframing perspectives
Conflict resolution
Therapy process
Anger management techniques
Planning and organization
Relationship insights
Supportive communication
Self-care importance
Communication strategies
Emotional validation
Hurricane preparedness
Future Topic Category
We gathered insight into the user’s desires of what they would want to discuss post-session.
The follow categories were identified from open-ended user responses to the future topic question:
Continue current focus
Self-care strategies
Nothing specific
Anxiety management
Relationship dynamics
Stress management
Emotional well-being
Anger management
Accountability
Undecided
Family dynamics
Grief processing
Self-validation
Pet therapy Results
User Engagement Statistics
The following results pertain to chats collected via our internal and public deployments ranging from September 25th, 2024 to October 15th, 2024.
Total Users 86
Total Chat Sessions 164
Total Completed Chats (User completed wrap-up questions) 62 (37.8% of total chat sessions)
Average Utterance Count for Completed Chats 17
Standard Deviation of Utterance Count for Completed Chats 6.84
Detected high-risk scenarios (Public) 1
User Issues Reported 0
Sentiment Statistics
User Question: "So, how are you feeling now compared to when we started chatting?"
Category Count Percent:
Positive (”better”) 52 83.8%
Neutral 10 16.2%
Negative 0 0%
We did not find any harmful chats in qualitative review.
Insight Category Statistics
User Question: "What's one thing you're taking away from our talk today?"
Category Count Percent
Coping strategies 15 24.6%
Self-care strategies 12 19.7%
Self-reflection 9 14.8%
Emotional awareness 5 8.2%
Boundary setting 3 4.9%
Self-awareness 2 3.3%
Work-life balance 2 3.3%
Emotional regulation 2 3.3%
Reframing perspectives 2 3.3%
Conflict resolution 1 1.6%
Therapy process 1 1.6%
Anger management techniques 1 1.6%
Planning and organization 1 1.6%
Relationship insights 1 1.6%
Supportive communication 1 1.6%
Self-care importance 1 1.6%
Communication strategies 1 1.6%
Emotional validation 1 1.6%
Hurricane preparedness 1 1.6%
Future Topic Statistics
User Question: "Is there anything you'd like to focus on next time we chat?"
Category Count Percent
Continue current focus 12 19.4%
Self-care strategies 11 17.7%
Nothing specific 8 12.9%
Anxiety management 7 11.3%
Relationship dynamics 4 6.5%
Stress management 4 6.5%
Emotional well-being 4 6.5%
Anger management 2 3.2%
Accountability 2 3.2%
Undecided 2 3.2%
Family dynamics 2 3.2%
Grief processing 2 3.2%
Self-validation 1 1.6%
Pet therapy 1 1.6%
Discussion
Comparison to Existing Solutions
Due to the anonymous and public nature of collection, we did not conduct any analysis against existing systems. Baumel et al. found that the median open-rate for most wellness applications was 4%. [4] While their study did not discuss churn-rate while interacting with applications, we find that 37.8% of users who opened Opal completed their 10 minute session, and that 19.4% would like to continue their current focus in the next session potentially indicating stronger retention. In future works, we aim to study the retention rate on conversational between-session interventions when they are connected to the client’s treatment plan.
Limitations & Potential Biases
This report is post-hoc and strictly exploratory. We therefore acknowledge the lack of control group and demographic information as a limitation to our findings. Our analysis only includes sessions for which the user engaged with the system to the end and answered the provided wrap-up questions. The sentiment of incomplete conversations cannot be inferred since users may end the chat if they find the chat irrelevant, or satisfactory. We plan to further explore the efficacy of our particular system in controlled settings integrated into care methodologies in the future.
Ethical Considerations
The deployment of AI systems in mental health contexts requires careful consideration of ethical implications and potential risks. While Opal Wellness aims to provide accessible wellness support, we acknowledge the broader ethical challenges of using AI in this domain. These include the risk of users developing emotional attachment to the system, potential over-reliance on automated support, and the complexity of maintaining appropriate boundaries between AI assistance and professional care. We address these concerns through clear scope limitations, consistent reminders of the system's non-therapeutic nature, and immediate redirection to professional resources when appropriate. Moreover, we employ an anonymous data collection approach and opt-in sharing mechanisms to honor user privacy and autonomy. We further adhere to the National Board of Certified Counselors official guidelines for the safe use of AI systems in mental healthcare, [11] and propose our own ethical values system. The following ethical guidelines were developed in consultation with mental health professionals and inform all aspects of our system design, from prompt engineering to user interface choices:
Outcomes First
Principally, any use of AI in mental healthcare should directly or indirectly result in measurably better treatment outcomes for clients.
Transparency
All participants in the application of an AI system should be informed of its function, limitation, purpose, and data governance.
Control
Clinicians always remain in control of AI agents and their interaction with clients. Experts always remain in-the-loop of AI workflows and may review, edit, override and exercise equal or greater privilege over AI systems.
Consent
All participation in the application of an AI system should be consensual and with full understanding of these core tenets.
In the future, we plan to implement additional safety checks on user input and model output at each turn of dialog. These safety checks will be implemented using a feedback loop with the LLM, in which a different prompt (or different LLM altogether) reviews the user input and model output for high-risk scenarios. Our internal system can then halt these interactions before they escalate.
Future Work
System Improvements
Input / Output Verification
Future iterations of Opal Wellness will require robust verification mechanisms to ensure system responses remain within therapeutic boundaries. We plan to implement:
Pre-response validation using a separate model prompt to classify responses for therapeutic appropriateness
Post-response validation using a separate model prompt to deny model responses which could result in high-risk scenarios
Safe Response Test Harness
To maintain system safety and reliability for open-ended conversational interfaces, we propose developing a comprehensive test harness that includes:
Automated generation of challenging user scenarios
Continuous evaluation of system responses against therapeutic guidelines
Integration testing with crisis detection systems
Regular validation of the
[[WRN]]and[[WRAPUP]]token mechanisms
Long-term Efficacy Studies
To better understand the impact of AI-assisted wellness support, we propose several longitudinal studies:
Controlled trials comparing Opal Wellness to traditional between-session journaling
Assessment of user engagement patterns over extended periods
Analysis of therapeutic outcomes when Opal is used as a supplement to professional care
Investigation of demographic factors affecting system efficacy
Evaluation of optimal interaction duration and frequency
Integration with Professional Care
Future development will focus on enhancing Opal's role as a supplementary tool for professional mental health care:
Integration into our clinician dashboard for monitoring patient interactions
Implementing controls for clinicians to give customized instructions to the system for high relevance to the receiving client
Enhanced reporting mechanisms for tracking patient progress
Controls for clinician to limit generative access to Opal for high-risk clients at their professional discretion
These improvements will be developed in close consultation with mental health professionals and with careful consideration of our existing ethical guidelines and privacy requirements.
Conclusion
In this article, we conducted a post-hoc analysis of anonymous Opal Wellness user interactions for their sentiment, impact, and user perception. We find that our wellness conversational system exhibits promise as a between-session psychotherapy intervention tool with 83.8% of users reporting immediate improvement to their mental state (16.2% neutral), while exhibiting high engagement compared to existing wellness apps. Users reported coping mechanisms as a helpful takeaway from our application (24.6%), and generally reported that their session aligned with expectations for future sessions (19.4%). We found that our base model strongly follows complex instructions, including in high-risk situations, with 0 problem reports and no observed instances in which our model erroneously engaged in high-risk topics. Users who completed their interaction with Opal showed strong engagement with an average utterance count of 17. We acknowledge potential limitations due to the locality of our advertising, and anonymous reporting. Future work is required to assess the efficacy of conversational AI support integrated into care models under clinician instruction.
References
Raile, P. (2024). The usefulness of ChatGPT for psychotherapists and patients. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11, 47. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-023-02567-0
Conroy, J., Lin, L., & Ghaness, A. (2020, July 1). Why people aren't getting the care they need. Monitor on Psychology, 51(5). https://www.apa.org/monitor/2020/07/datapoint-care
Fulmer, R., Beeson, E. T., Sheperis, C., Rosello, D., & Edelman, R. (2023). Artificial Intelligence for mental health support during COVID-19: Experiences of graduate counseling students. Journal of Technology in Counselor Education and Supervision, 4(1), Article 5. https://doi.org/10.61888/2692-4129.1094
Baumel, A., Muench, F., Edan, S., & Kane, J. (2019). Objective user engagement with mental health apps: Systematic search and panel-based usage analysis. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 21(9), Article e14567. https://doi.org/10.2196/14567
Payne, K. (2024, March 12). AI chatbot pushed teen to kill himself, lawsuit alleges. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/chatbot-ai-lawsuit-suicide-teen-artificial-intelligence-9d48adc572100822fdbc3c90d1456bd0
Fitzpatrick, K., Darcy, A., & Vierhile, M. (2017). Delivering cognitive behavior therapy to young adults with symptoms of depression and anxiety using a fully automated conversational agent (Woebot): A randomized controlled trial. JMIR Mental Health, 4(2), Article e19. https://doi.org/10.2196/mental.7785
Mugerwa, S., & Holden, J. D. (2012). Writing therapy: A new tool for general practice? British Journal of General Practice, 62(605), 661-663. https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp12X659457
Chen, K., Huang, J. J., & Torous, J. (2024). Hybrid care in mental health: A framework for understanding care, research, and future opportunities. NPP—Digital Psychiatry Neuroscience, 2, 16. https://doi.org/10.1038/s44277-024-00016-7
Jin, H., Chen, R., Zhou, A., Zhang, Y., & Wang, H. (2024). GUARD: Role-playing to Generate Natural-language Jailbreakings to Test Guideline Adherence of Large Language Models. ArXiv.org. https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03299
Shannon, C. E., & Weaver, W. (1948). A Mathematical Theory of Communication. Bell System Technical Journal, 27(4), 623–656. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1538-7305.1948.tb00917.x
Hargett, B., & Parsons, J. (2024, April 12). Ethical principles for artificial intelligence in counseling. National Board for Certified Counselors. https://nbcc.org/assets/Ethics/EthicalPrinciples_for_AI.pdf?_zs=sv3vQ1&_zl=4rBT7
Beyond Note-Taking: How Top Practices Track Client Progress Between Sessions
Your client arrives for their session, and you spend the first 20-30 minutes catching up on everything that's happened since you last met. By the time you get to meaningful therapeutic work, your session time is nearly half over. Sound familiar?
We call this the reactive therapy model, where important topics are presented and discussed within the same session, and we found it’s especially a problem for younger clients. We find this causes an often overlooked problem of slow treatment, which can manifest as retention or treatment satisfaction issues later on. To see this firsthand, look no further than psychotherapy’s most receptive cohort—Gen Z. While 50% of Gen Z have been to therapy, only 1 in 5 are currently in it, with 40% searching.
The Hidden Cost of Inaction
Delayed interventions can lead to suboptimal clinical outcomes. When issues go unaddressed for days or weeks until the next appointment, clients are left without proper coping strategies during critical moments, and may apply a different bias when recalling events, compared to how they experienced those events in the moment.
The impact of this disconnect goes beyond just inefficient sessions. When practices don't adapt to address these needs between sessions, we face several risks:
Higher client attrition rates: Clients leave when they don’t see results quick enough, or feel there isn’t a ‘fit’
Reduced practice revenue: Clients turn to asynchronous alternatives such as text therapy or wellness apps
Missed opportunities for early intervention: Clients will naturally recall events differently than how they experienced them
Increased therapist burnout from difficult (“heavy”) sessions: Reactive care necessarily requires on-the-fly interventions, with higher surprisal
Practical Solutions for Between-Session Engagement
After speaking with several fellow clinicians, we noticed three major themes in how practices are managing inter-session engagement today:
Structured Check-In Systems
Implementing daily mood rating scales provides a consistent way to monitor client wellbeing, while simple yes/no questions can track their application of therapeutic skills. For clients requiring additional support during challenging periods, scheduling brief text check-ins through a secure direct-message system can provide timely intervention opportunities.
Implementation Tip
Start with just one method and make it as frictionless as possible. The easier it is, the more likely clients will participate.
Digital Documentation Tools
Support client engagement through guided journaling prompts that align with their specific treatment goals and objectives. For those who find writing challenging, voice notes offer an accessible alternative. Custom tracking sheets can be developed to monitor particular behaviors or symptoms that are relevant to each client's situation.
Implementation Tip
Let clients choose their preferred method. Some may love writing, while others might prefer quick voice memos.
Progress Visualization
This especially powerful evidence-based method has proven highly effective within Client-Directed Outcome-Informed and Patient-Centered Documentation treatment models, demonstrating 85% more successful treatment outcomes. The core approach centers on creating opportunities for you and your client to jointly interpret their progress at each session touchpoint. This includes collaborative note taking and sharing, creating visual representations of skill usage, and maintaining clear visibility of progress toward specific therapeutic goals.
Implementation Tip
Make progress visible and celebratory. Gen Z clients particularly value seeing tangible evidence of their growth.
Making It Sustainable
The key challenge isn't just implementing these tools—It's doing so without creating additional friction for ourselves or our clients.
Set Clear Expectations
From the initial intake, it's essential to explain how between-session tracking can enhance treatment outcomes and provide valuable insights into the client's progress. While participation should remain optional, emphasize its benefits and encourage clients to engage in the process. Establish specific times when you'll review submissions to set realistic expectations around feedback and responses.
Create Efficient Workflows
Success with between-session tracking requires establishing dedicated blocks of time for reviewing client data. Streamline this process by developing templates for documentation that capture essential information while minimizing administrative burden. Make the review process part of your regular session preparation routine, allowing insights to inform your therapeutic approach.
Focus on Actionable Insights
When reviewing tracking data, concentrate on identifying patterns that can meaningfully inform treatment directions and interventions. Use these insights to proactively adjust therapeutic approaches before issues escalate. Share relevant observations with clients in a way that enhances their understanding and engagement in the therapeutic process, making the data collection effort worthwhile for everyone involved.
Evidence-Based Solutions with Opal
While these strategies can be implemented manually, modern practices are turning to specialized tools like Opal to make the process repeatable for high caseloads for the following reasons:
Trust In Outcomes
The impact of Opal's guided support features is demonstrated through impressive user satisfaction metrics, with 83% of users reporting immediate improvement in their wellbeing after engaging with the platform. Practices have seen tangible benefits in their capacity, accepting 5 additional clients due to streamlined case management. The platform's 97% documentation accuracy significantly reduces the time spent on administrative tasks, allowing therapists to focus more on direct client care.
Client-Centered Design
Opal's platform is specifically engineered to align with modern therapeutic needs, particularly resonating with Gen Z's digital-first preferences. The system provides continuous 24/7 support that's informed by each therapist's unique approach and expertise. Through thoughtful design, it facilitates the creation of meaningful briefings that strengthen the therapeutic alliance between client and practitioner.
Practice Growth
The platform serves as a catalyst for practice expansion, enabling clinicians to confidently increase their client base while maintaining quality of care. Enhanced client engagement leads to improved retention rates, creating more stable and sustainable practices. This optimization of practice management and service delivery translates to significant financial benefits, generating an average of $30,000 in additional yearly revenue per clinician.
In Short
The future of therapy isn't just about what happens in the room anymore. In a world where clients are increasingly demanding continuous support models, we as clinicians should respond accordingly to ensure the best possible outcomes for our clients and their unique needs. Therapy is a two way street, and ultimately these practices result in better retention, satisfaction, and practice efficiency to better serve a larger cohort of patients.
Ready to learn more about Opal?
Visit our website to access our safety and efficacy whitepaper, with key indicators towards better outcomes for clients:
Keywords: AI therapy notes, mental health technology 2024, therapy documentation software, reduce therapist burnout, improve therapy outcomes, mental health practice management, AI in healthcare, therapy efficiency, digital mental health, automated therapy notes
Q&A: A Client's Perspective on AI in Therapy
For our founding blog post, we interviewed a client who volunteered to share their journey with therapy, and their perspective of how Artificial Intelligence fits into it. To us, this is a very special post—There is no more important topic than the human connection in therapy. In order to share their story candidly, they have asked to remain anonymous. We hope their perspective leads others to share their journeys as well.
Anonymous
For our founding blog post, we interviewed a client who volunteered to share their journey with therapy, and their perspective of how Artificial Intelligence fits into it. To us, this is a very special post—There is no more important topic than the human connection in therapy. In order to share their story candidly, they have asked to remain anonymous. We hope their perspective leads others to share their journeys as well.
Q: What was your reaction when you first learned about AI being used in therapy sessions?
A: When I first heard about therapists using AI in sessions to listen to our conversations, I was very skeptical. As someone who's been in therapy on and off for almost 10 years, the idea of bringing AI into this deeply personal space raised some concerns. It felt surreal, especially considering how quickly these new tools are being introduced in our everyday lives, let alone in the healthcare industry.
Q: What considerations came to mind regarding AI in therapy?
A: My primary consideration was privacy. In an age where data breaches make headlines and targeted ads seem to read our minds, I wondered how I could be sure that my most intimate thoughts and feelings would remain confidential. I also thought about the role of human therapists and how AI might impact that. A one-on-one conversation with my counselor is incredibly valuable to me, and I wouldn't want to lose that personal connection.
Q: How did your perspective on AI in therapy evolve over time?
A: I took a step back and thought about all the ways I use AI in my daily life to save time and run my life and work more efficiently. I realized that if AI can help me manage my calendar, sort my emails, and help me figure out the best way to respond to emails, it could potentially enhance my therapy sessions too. I also learned that human therapists aren't going anywhere, and many AI tools are simply being used to help therapists with their workload, which made me feel good. After all, my therapist deserves to take care of themselves and their workload too.
Q: What factors do you think are important when introducing AI into therapy?
A: Transparency is crucial. My openness to AI in therapy hinges on my therapist's clear communication. As long as she explains the tools and how they could make our sessions more effective, I am willing to give it a try. I've been seeing her for almost two years, and I genuinely believe she has my best interests at heart. I also think that AI companies in the healthcare space should make their privacy standards readily available and easy to read on their websites for clients. That can only help build trust and understanding.
“As long as she explains the tools and how they could
make our sessions more effective, I am willing to give it a try.”
Q: What are your thoughts on privacy in AI-assisted therapy?
A: Therapists are already bound by strict HIPAA regulations to protect client privacy. Surely, those same protections would extend to any technology integrated into our sessions. This realization, combined with the transparency from my therapist and the AI companies, has helped alleviate many of my initial privacy concerns. It's reassuring to know that there are established protocols in place to protect sensitive information.
Q: How has the integration of AI affected your therapy experience?
A: After learning more about AI in therapy and the privacy measures in place, I've come to see how it can make a positive impact on the therapeutic journey. AI tools offer exciting possibilities for enhancing mental health care, making it more effective and efficient. They've helped streamline some aspects of my sessions, allowing my therapist and me to focus more deeply on important issues. However, it's important to note that AI complements, rather than replaces, the human connection at the heart of the therapeutic process. Our mental health journey is deeply personal, and I appreciate that the AI tools respect that fundamental truth. With an approach that prioritizes trust, transparency, and privacy, AI has enhanced my therapy experience in ways I didn't initially expect. It's opened up new avenues for insight and progress in my mental health journey.
“It's important to note that AI complements, rather than replaces, the human connection at the heart of the therapeutic process.
Our mental health journey is deeply personal, and I appreciate that the AI tools respect that fundamental truth.”
Welcome.
How technology can improve our mental health is one of the most exciting horizons of our time. We are on the precipice of a new era in mental healthcare, where innovative technologies are poised to revolutionize how we understand, treat, and support mental well-being.
Welcome to our Blog, The Human Connection, where we will explore diverse perspectives on artificial intelligence, digital mental health, and how their intersection improves the most effective part of the therapeutic process: the human connection.
How technology can improve our mental health is one of the most exciting horizons of our time. We are on the precipice of a new era in mental healthcare, where innovative technologies are poised to revolutionize how we understand, treat, and support mental well-being.
Welcome to our Blog, The Human Connection, where we will explore diverse perspectives on artificial intelligence, digital mental health, and how their intersection improves the most effective part of the therapeutic process: the human connection.
How We Got Here
Our journey to create Opal was not a short one. It wasn’t an idea that popped up at the dinner table, or came to us on a whim. It was the result of carefully watching how the landscapes and opinions of early digital mental health companies changed over time, learning what worked and where there was still work to be done. What we found was winning formula on how we wanted to make a difference.
Understanding Is Everything
Charting in healthcare can often feel like busywork when we don’t see clearly how it helps us. For the longest time, this documentation helped us be aware of our patients and their needs, but didn’t help us understand them on a deeper level to improve their care. But what does it mean to improve understanding? It goes further than generating progress notes, or inferring diagnostic codes. It is found between the lines (and between sessions) and most importantly, the changes and progress of the client from session to session.
Communication Is How We Build It
Opal helps solve two of the most fundamental issues in healthcare overall: patient-provider communication, and provider-provider communication. The former is more important for mental healthcare than any other discipline of healthcare, as field where relationships are the fundamental building block of the treatment.
“Opal helps solve the most fundamental challenge of mental healthcare: patient-provider communication.”
We strongly believe that therapy works because of the human connection. No AI system can replace therapy, though many may try, because those systems are not human. Clients may seek counseling for a variety of reasons, but central to them is the mutual, equal desire of human empathy.
We are delighted that you may join us on this journey.
Cole Smith, CEO